This only works if they don't choose to exile all graveyards when they cast the spell, something a lot of people do anyway, and likely only works once against someone who will choose to hit 'yards next time, but it's better than scooping to the laziest card ever designed
And why should we care about getting tempted by The Ring
In a similar vein, Faith's Fetters lets you disable even tricky permanents (I'm looking at you Maze of Ith), all while gaining back a little bit of life
Their transformed side adds more juice by giving unblockability twice and tapping their lands
While Judith, Carnage Connoisseur offers unique abilities, there may be better options for similar strategies, such as Young Pyromancer or Monastery Mentor, which provide consistent token generation